As the list above shows there are plenty of reasons to do a Shakedown Hike. To stress the point I made in the first section, a Shakedown Hike is more than just about gear. It’s about learning about yourself and gaining confidence.
Reading online forums and what others do is good for two things: either confirming or conflicting what you hopefully already figured out for yourself. If that process helps you confirm what you learned and gives you confidence, then by all means do it. Whatever you do, don’t simple read what others think is best, learn it for yourself.
Skipping the experience part and going straight to actual hiking would be great, but it unfortunately doesn’t work that way. Trying to do so leads one to being unprepared, dangerous situations, and quite possibly quitting your hike early. Don’t make this mistake and waste all the time, effort, and money you invested into your adventure to throw it all away because you skipped a Shakedown Hike.
I’ve accumulated well over 15,000 miles of hiking and bikepacking experience and I still do Shakedown hikes/rides today. Learning should never stop, and hiking is no different.